A lesson for CBS: Live fact-checking is incompatible with good debate moderation

Sept. 20, Ben Voth, a professor of rhetoric and director of debate at SMU Dallas, for a piece critical of the way some media outlets have been conducting presidential debates in recent years. Published in The Hill under the heading A lesson for CBS: Live fact-checking is incompatible with good debate moderation: https://tinyurl.com/mrxvrccw 

 

Lindsey Davis and David Muir of ABC News moderated ABC’s Sept. 10 presidential debate between former President Donald Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris. The debate, the second of the year, demonstrates the collapse of the traditional Commission on Presidential Debate forums that came into being in 1987. The commission originally planned to host a series of debates this fall that neither of the political parties would agree to for their campaigns.

The collapse of that process led to the current regimen of media network debate events now hosted by CNN and ABC. Most analysts recognize that Muir and Davis engaged in arguably partisan fact checking against the Trump campaign, raising inherent questions about how the next debate among vice presidential candidates Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio) and Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz (D) might be moderated by CBS News journalists Norah O’Donnell and Margaret Brennan.

Continue reading “A lesson for CBS: Live fact-checking is incompatible with good debate moderation”

Paying More Attention to His Appearance Than Hers

August 12, Rhonda Garelick, distinguished professor of English and Journalism at SMU Dallas, for a piece about the Kamala Harris/Tim Walz democratic presidential ticket and how age, gender and appearance can be muted or magnified in the presentation. Published in Garelick’s New York Times ‘Face Forward’ column under the heading Paying More Attention to His Appearance Than Hers: https://tinyurl.com/uzaemwbx 

Historically, women in the public eye have been described as women first, and everything else second: “women politicians,” not just politicians; “women authors”; or “women artists,” for example. Along with the labeling comes the long list of expectations, especially in politics, which typically breaks down into three basic categories: body (Is she pretty enough, or maybe too pretty? Does she dress badly or too well?); temperament (Is she nice or overbearing? Is she too emotional? Too ambitious?); and family (Is she a childless cat lady? A mother? Is her husband really running the show?).

Remarkably though, Kamala Harris seems to be evading much of this, starting with her perceived age. Ms. Harris will be 60 in two months. Yet she seems just somehow outside the category of age — not young, but also not old or even middle age. True, she is more than 20 years younger than President Biden and telegraphs energy and exuberance. She dances; she sings; she laughs; she’s friends with Quavo. But when she rebukes a disruptive protester at a rally with her trademark, “I’m speaking,” she is the adult in the room — fully mature, yet nowhere near “old.” And also free of the staid or matronly connotations of the “middle-age woman.”

Continue reading “Paying More Attention to His Appearance Than Hers”

We need a Lincoln right now

July 29, Dallas Gingles, assistant dean of hybrid education and associate professor in the Perkins School of Theology at SMU Dallas, for a commentary positing that the country needs a leader today with the wisdom and religious guideposts of Abraham Lincoln. Published in the Dallas Morning News under the heading We need a Lincoln right now: https://tinyurl.com/mtyt7tjd 

I teach ethics and theology at Southern Methodist University, and this fall I’m offering a course on Presidential Rhetoric and Political Theology. Beginning with Lincoln’s second inaugural address, we’ll examine the ways presidents have used theological themes as a way of helping explain the nation to itself.

I’ve been thinking about this topic for at least the past decade, but listening to this year’s debate between President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump, I was struck by how important this tradition is to our shared self-understanding as a country, and about how impoverished we are because neither Biden nor Trump truly inhabits it. Whether Vice President Kamala Harris better embodies the Lincoln paradigm remains to be seen.

Continue reading “We need a Lincoln right now”